PROJECT EXAMPLES

Below you will find some examples of our project work. Please do not hesitate to get in touch if you would like further information.

 

Hart Local Plan - Appraisal for Winchfield Parish Council


We prepared a report on behalf of Winchfield Parish Council which addressed the landscape constraints to an ‘area of search’ (AoS) for a new settlement identified in the Proposed Submission Version of the Hart Local Plan, February 2018 (Draft Policy SS3). The AoS includes about 75% of Winchfield Parish.

Our report and its accompanying graphics demonstrated the valuable green infrastructure function of the countryside which comprises the AoS. Particularly for the residents of Hook and Fleet, and the surrounding historic villages of Dogmersfield, Odiham and Hartley Wintney. Our findings serve as evidence that the new settlement envisaged by Draft Policy SS3 would result in significant landscape and visual harm and be at risk of harming components within the landscape which hold high landscape, amenity, and heritage value.


 

Wethersfield Road, Finchingfield, Essex


In 2017 Michelle Bolger gave landscape evidence on behalf of Braintree District Council with regard to an appeal by Gladman Developments Ltd, against the refusal of planning permission for up to 80 dwellings on land off Wethersfield Road, Finchingfield, Essex.  Michelle argued successfully that the site should be considered a valued landscape with regard to paragraph 109 NPPF due to the contribution that it made to the character and setting of Finchingfield. 

Despite the fact that the Council could not demonstrate a five-year supply of housing land the Inspector found, on application of paragraph 134 NPPF, that the public benefits of the scheme did not outweigh the harm to the heritage assets. Further, he found that paragraph 109 NPPF to be a policy in the Framework which restricts development, and that public benefits did not outweigh the harm to the valued landscape.

Counsel:  Dr Ashley Bowes
Planning Witness:  Alison Hutchinson, Hutchinsons Planning & Development Consultants
Cultural Heritage Witness:  Adrian Gascoyne, Essex CC

PLANNING DECISION


 

Gascoyne Cecil Estates, Symondshyde, Hertfordshire


Watercolour images: © Brooks Murray Architects

Gascoyne Cecil Estates (GCE), the owners of Hatfield House in Hertfordshire, are actively involved in the ongoing Welwyn Hatfield Local Plan process.  As major landowners within the Borough they are promoting sites through the local plan process including an urban extensions, high tech commercial development and a new 'estate village' at Symondshyde.  GCE are also promoting the development of a major corridor of Green Infrastructure linking Hatfield, Welwyn Garden City and Hatford.

MBELC has provided a range of landscape advice for GCE including initial appraisals of landscape and visual issues and the preparation of a Landscape Vision for land between the edge of Hatfield and the new village at Symondshyde. 

Client: Gascoyne Cecil Estates
Architect:  Brooks Murray Architects
Planning Consultant:  JB Planning
Transport Consultant:  WSP


 

St Osyth Priory, Essex


St Osyth Priory is a heritage complex, including more than twenty heritage assets, near the coast in Essex.  The Priory, which includes a Registered Park, is on the Heritage at Risk register.   The current owners have been working for the more than fifteen years on enabling proposals to fund restoration of the buildings and landscape, and to bring the whole estate back into viable use. 

Michelle Bolger has been involved in the site since 2011 as part of a multi-disciplinary team, originally with Liz Lake Associates.  She was responsible for the LVIA for enabling development which involved new buildings within the Registered Park and residential development on adjacent land.  Michelle prepared and gave landscape evidence at two inquiries following the failure of Tendring District Council to determine the applications. 

Although the appeals were initially dismissed the decision was subsequently quashed and during the second inquiry in November 2016 Tendring District Council granted permission for revised applications.

Client:  City and Country (Residential ) Ltd
Counsel:  Peter Village QC, 39 Essex St Chambers
Planning Consultant:  John Boyd, JB Planning
Cultural Heritage Consultant:  Chris Miele, Montagu Evans


 

Griffe Grange Wind Turbine Development, Derbyshire


Michelle Bolger provided expert landscape advice for Derbyshire Dales District Council to support their refusal of an application for wind turbine development on a site close to the Peak District National Park.  

A scheme nearby at Carsington Pastures has been approved at appeal and the appellant argued that this indicated the site was suitable for wind turbines and the presence of existing turbine development reduced the sensitivity of the landscape.

Michelle argued successfully that rather than reducing the sensitivity of the landscape the presence of exiting turbines had reduced its capacity for additional turbines.  The inspector agreed with her description of the existing landscape character of the Griffe Grange Valley and her conclusion that the appeal site was important to the setting of the National Park.

Counsel:  Thea Osmund, No 5 Chambers
Planning Witness:  Jonathon Bradbury, Derbyshire Dales DC
Cultural Heritage Witness:  Steve Baker, Derbyshire CC

Planning Decision


 

Other Appeals


Other appeals in 2017 where Michelle successfully defended the landscape reasons for refusal are:

Finchingfield Road, Steeple Bumpstead – Braintree District Council

Thrapston Road, Brampton – Huntingdonshire District Council